Trap Squat: Fugitive Edition

CALIFORNIA, Md. — A 40-minute standoff at a vacant, waterless house on Thursday, Aug. 7, 2025, ended a months-long, multi-county manhunt for a woman wanted in a series of burglaries and thefts, and simultaneously led to the capture of a second woman who was indicted in June on major felony drug trafficking charges. A third individual was also arrested for squatting in the home.

The incident began when St. Mary’s County sheriff’s deputies descended on a residence on Dahlia Circle to serve multiple active warrants on Whitney Anne Arnold, 39, of Mechanicsville. According to charging documents, the occupants refused to exit for approximately 40 minutes before Arnold finally surrendered and was arrested.

While taking Arnold into custody, deputies found two other people inside the home, which the owner confirmed had been vacant for four months with no running water. The second woman was identified as Amanda Lynn Cantrell, 41, of Lexington Park. When told to exit, Cantrell allegedly refused and tried to flee back into the house before being detained. The third person was James Richard Arnold, 63, who told deputies he had been staying in the house for a month without permission, despite knowing the owner.

The arrest brought an end to a frantic search for Whitney Arnold, who was wanted for a crime spree allegedly committed in April 2025. In St. Mary’s County, she faces charges including first-degree burglary for allegedly forcing open a sliding glass door at a Lexington Park apartment on April 11 and stealing $400 worth of electronics. In Calvert County, she is charged with stealing a $1,023 gaming PC and other items from the Prince Frederick Walmart on April 12. Bench warrants were issued in both counties after she repeatedly failed to appear for court. Arnold also faces numerous traffic charges in St. Mary’s County Circuit Court from a Jan. 15 traffic stop, including theft of a registration tag.

Her housemate, Amanda Cantrell, was the subject of a nine-count grand jury indictment filed in June. The indictment includes severe felony charges for possession of a large amount of fentanyl and possession with intent to distribute fentanyl and cocaine from an incident on June 1, 2025. That fentanyl charge alone carries a mandatory minimum sentence of five years in prison.

All three individuals were charged with a new count of fourth-degree burglary for squatting in the vacant home. Court records show all three were released on their own recognizance after their arrests and have multiple upcoming court dates for their various charges.

---

Got a tip or photo? Text us at 888-871-NEWS (6397) or email news@thebaynet.com.

Join The BayNet Membership for exclusive perks and zero ads.

Don’t miss a story—sign up for our newsletter!